Definitely! We have a lot of customers who do this.
A single sensor can be paired with any number of mobile devices at the same time, and a single mobile device can be paired with any number of sensors.
Without a gateway
Add the sensor to each mobile device, just as you did on the first one. Each phone reads the sensor directly over Bluetooth. Settings like sensor names and alerts are kept separately on each phone, so you'll need to set them up on each one.
With a G1 or G2 WiFi Gateway
Don't re-add the sensors. Instead, log the additional mobile device into the same SensorPush account, and all your sensors, gateways and settings will appear automatically and stay in sync. Here's how: Can more than one mobile device be logged into the Gateway simultaneously?
Learn more: How many phones or other mobile devices can I use with the same sensor or Gateway?